Skip to content
GreenwoodAssistants
Articles & guides
Comparisons · 7 min read

Hiring a virtual assistant vs hiring an employee: the honest comparison

Both get work off your plate. One comes with payroll, pension and a desk. Here's how to choose without guessing.

When you're up to your neck in admin, "I need to get some help" can mean two very different things: hire someone, or find someone who can help. From the outside they look the same — a person who answers your emails and keeps things moving. The commitment behind them is completely different.

This is the straight version of that comparison, including the parts where an employee is the better answer.

What an employee actually costs

The salary is the part you see. It's also the smallest part.

  • Recruitment: writing the ad, screening, interviews, and the weeks it takes
  • Employer's National Insurance and pension contributions
  • Holiday pay, sick pay and pension enrolment
  • Payroll, contracts and the paperwork that follows every change
  • Equipment, software licences and somewhere to sit
  • Training them in how your business works
  • Paying the same amount in your quietest month as in your busiest
  • The cost of getting it wrong: notice periods, and starting again

What a virtual assistant costs

You pay for the hours you actually use, and nothing else. No recruitment fee, no employer's National Insurance, no pension duty, no desk, no laptop, no payroll. If a month is quiet, you aren't paying for hours you didn't need. If it's busy, you add some.

With Greenwood you start with a paid trial, so you can see how it works before committing to anything longer. After that you're on a monthly package, and you can change your hours as your business changes.

Where an employee is the better answer

We'd rather be straight with you: sometimes a virtual assistant is the wrong shape.

  • You need someone on site, in the workshop or the office, most days
  • The work is physical: stock, deliveries, customers at a counter
  • You genuinely have full-time, all-day work, every week, all year
  • You want someone who grows into a second-in-command role over years
  • The role needs a licence or qualification you'd employ for directly
  • You want one person who is yours, not shared with other clients

Where a virtual assistant wins

  • You need help for a handful of hours a week, not a full week of hours
  • You want to start this month, not after a recruitment process
  • Your workload moves with the seasons
  • You don't want to be an employer: payroll, sickness, holiday, disputes
  • You'd rather try before you commit
  • You want cover arranged for you when someone's away
  • You need a range of skills: some admin, some bookkeeping, some marketing

The question nobody asks you

Before you compare costs, count the hours. Not the hours you wish you had, but the ones that genuinely need doing by someone other than you.

If it's a few hours a week, an employee is the wrong shape: you'd be paying a salary and on-costs for a fraction of a person's time. If it's full-time, every day, with a queue out the door, hire the employee — we'll happily tell you so.

You don't have to choose forever

A virtual assistant often sits before an employee, not instead of one. Plenty of owners use an assistant to get on top of the backlog, learn what actually needs doing, and then write a job description based on real work rather than a guess. Some keep the assistant alongside the employee: one person on the tools or the front desk, one person on the paperwork.

A quick way to decide

  • Only a few hours of real work a week → a virtual assistant usually wins on cost and flexibility
  • Full-time, on site, every day → an employee
  • You want to try it before committing → a virtual assistant
  • You don't want the employer paperwork → a virtual assistant
  • You need one person, all day, all year → an employee

Whichever you choose

The mistake is the same either way: getting help without knowing what you'd actually hand over. Write down the ten jobs you'd most like off your plate. If most of them are emails, quotes, invoices, bookings and chasing, that's assistant work — and it's the part you were never going to enjoy doing anyway.

See what a Greenwood assistant costs

Compare the monthly packages →

Not sure yet?

See what you could hand off

Six quick questions about your business. You'll see the tasks your assistant could take on, the hours you'd get back, and which package fits.

Ready when you are

Start your two-week trial

A UK-based assistant on your quick wins from week one. If it's not a fit, there's nothing more to pay.